Thank you for the feedback, I admit I wasn’t going for cuckolding, as that isn’t doing anything for me either. But I enjoyed writing an erotically inexperienced man seeing his love being raped, resulting in a nasty reaction due to his own biases and upbringing. Sebastian is not the hero of the story merely the point of view I chose.Nickamano wrote: Fri Apr 18, 2025 6:42 pm Over all, I enjoyed this one. Even though there were aspects of it I don't like (not due to the writing) I'm never a fan of cuckold. This isn't strictly speaking that, but for me there is definitely an unpleasant cuckold aftertaste and it had me distracted by thought's of how the POV character could be looking for ways to escape, obviously not realistic, but it took me away from the action, of course that isn't a criticism aimed at the author, that's a me thing and a personal taste thing.
The other 'bad aftertaste' was already mentioned by Claire - his attitude to Valentina after the rapists had left. She should have come after him with a meat tenderiser for that little touch of icing on the cake. Again not a criticism aimed at the writer ("Shocker" is an apt name for that particular event though lol).
It was well written, concise, easy to follow, believable characters. Maybe have another look over from a grammatical perspective, there were some minor errors, a few misplaced commas (which we're all guilty of). Overall very enjoyable, other than the bits already mentionde.
Oh and I also enjoyed the "foreign" setting (depending on where one is from of course). It was an interesting little detail that gave the story an extra bit of original flavour. Thank you for sharing.
Gang Rape Galore Story Contest | Entries
Voting has begun! Time left: Timer Loading
Voting has begun! Time left: Timer Loading
Claire, what are you hiding from me? What are all these bots doing here?
Valentina
Forum rules
This forum is for publishing, reading and discussing rape fantasy (noncon) stories and consensual erotic fiction. Before you post your first story, please take five minutes to read the Quick Guide to Posting Stories and the Tag Guidelines.
If you are looking for a particular story, the story index might be helpful. It lists all stories alphabetically on one page. Please rate and comment on the stories you've read, thank you!
Story Filters
Language: English Stories | Deutsche Geschichten
Consent: Noncon | Consensual
Length: Flash | Short | Medium | Long
LGBT: Lesbian | Gay | Trans
Theme: Gang Rape | Female Rapist | SciFi | Fantasy
This forum is for publishing, reading and discussing rape fantasy (noncon) stories and consensual erotic fiction. Before you post your first story, please take five minutes to read the Quick Guide to Posting Stories and the Tag Guidelines.
If you are looking for a particular story, the story index might be helpful. It lists all stories alphabetically on one page. Please rate and comment on the stories you've read, thank you!
Story Filters
Language: English Stories | Deutsche Geschichten
Consent: Noncon | Consensual
Length: Flash | Short | Medium | Long
LGBT: Lesbian | Gay | Trans
Theme: Gang Rape | Female Rapist | SciFi | Fantasy
-
- Pillar of the Community
- Graduate
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2025 5:25 pm
Re: Valentina
My collected stories can be found here Shocking, positively shocking
Tags:
-
- Admin
- Research Assistant
- Posts: 757
- Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2025 7:21 am
Re: Valentina
That was close @Shocker, you almost had it! Maybe next time!
My stories: Claire's Cesspool of Sin. I'm always happy to receive a comment on my stories, even more so on an older one!
-
- Moderator
- Senior
- Posts: 141
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2025 11:46 am
Re: Valentina
A well-written and impactful story that makes one hate Sebastian. he deserves a few arrows come St Sebastian day.
I have to admit that I dislike the rapegasm trope, but its use was vital for the plot.

-
- Pillar of the Community
- Graduate
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2025 5:25 pm
Re: Valentina
Thanks for the feedback, Sebastian is a confused young man entirely lost in his upbringing and sexual inexperience. He is also a bit of a bigot asshole, I had no intention of having the readers leaving with sympathy for him.Lucius wrote: Sun Jun 01, 2025 1:58 pm A well-written and impactful story that makes one hate Sebastian. he deserves a few arrows come St Sebastian day.I have to admit that I dislike the rapegasm trope, but its use was vital for the plot.
Society quite often blames the victims of rape, he is just the stand in.
Like yourself I’m not much of a fan of rapegasm, but Has as little reference to her bodies reactions as Sebastian. Somebody had commented on the foreign setting before, and I chose this to let a strong catholic environment do the work for me.
My collected stories can be found here Shocking, positively shocking
-
- Sophomore
- Posts: 45
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2025 8:48 pm
Re: Valentina
In the beginning I was sure Sebastian would be the rapist, because he could not accept Valentinas reluctance anymore.
You subverted that expectation, and the end really caught me by surprise.
The choice of narrator was interesting, and his double standard gave it an interesting twist.
Allthough my favorite is the all-knowing third person perspective.
You subverted that expectation, and the end really caught me by surprise.
The choice of narrator was interesting, and his double standard gave it an interesting twist.
Allthough my favorite is the all-knowing third person perspective.
-
- Pillar of the Community
- Graduate
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2025 5:25 pm
Re: Valentina
I have been fond of the omniscient 3rd person perspective for a very long time, but have drifted towards 3rd person limited over the last few years, it makes it easier of including a twist without having to lie to the readers.AdmiralPiet wrote: Sun Jun 01, 2025 9:20 pm In the beginning I was sure Sebastian would be the rapist, because he could not accept Valentinas reluctance anymore.
You subverted that expectation, and the end really caught me by surprise.
The choice of narrator was interesting, and his double standard gave it an interesting twist.
Allthough my favorite is the all-knowing third person perspective.
My collected stories can be found here Shocking, positively shocking